The Pridwin Hotel - Shelter Island

The Pridwin Hotel - Shelter Island

$$$$|View on mapShelter Island, United States|
8.6
Great10 reviews
43 photos
Check rooms and rates
Check-in
Select date
-
Check-out
Select date
Rooms and Guests2 Guests, 1 room
The Pridwin Hotel - Shelter Island
$$$$
Overview

Overlooking the pool, Pridwin Hotel Shelter Island is 10 minutes by car from Greenport. This hotel offers a car park on site and a seasonal outdoor swimming pool.

Location

Shelter Island centre can be reached within 15 minutes' walk. The 4-star hotel is 10 minutes' drive from Railroad Museum of Long Island and 20 km from Hampton Bays. The private beach is located 400 metres away. Greenport Antique Carousel can also be found a 10-minute ride from The Pridwin Hotel.

Rooms

Certain rooms have a terrace and a seating area for your convenience. Guests can use a shower, along with a hair dryer.

Eat & Drink

Breakfast is offered in the restaurant every morning. The lively bar is also available.

Leisure & Business

A summer terrace and an outdoor pool area are provided at a charge. This accommodation indulges guests with billiards and a golf course as well as a steam room, a sauna, and an outdoor swimming pool. The Pridwin offers activities such as water sports activities, lawn tennis, and cycling.

Good to know
Check-in/Check-out
from 16:00-23:59
until 11:00
Amenities
Private parking is possible on site for free.
Wireless internet is available in public areas for free.
Other information
Breakfast
The hotel The Pridwin serves a full breakfast for free. 
Children & extra beds
There are no cots provided in a room. 
Pets
Pets are not allowed.
Building
Number of rooms:38
Price calendar
Check availability and prices for your dates now!

Rooms and availability

Guest Room
  • Max:
    2 persons
  • Water view
  • Air conditioning

Facilities

Main facilities

Free Wi-Fi

Free Wi-Fi in public areas

Free parking
Luggage storage
24-hour services

24-hour reception

Food/ Drinks

Bar/ Lounge area

Restaurant

Welcome drink

Fitness/ Gym

Fitness centre

Swimming pool

Seasonal outdoor pool

Saltwater pool

Heated swimming pool

Spa and relaxation

Back massage

Full body massage

Beauty treatment

Steam room

Sports & Fitness

  • Fitness centre
  • Water sports
  • Hiking
  • Cycling
  • Tennis court
  • Golf course
  • Billiard tables
  • Table tennis

Services

  • Housekeeping
  • Welcome drink

Dining

  • Restaurant
  • Bar/ Lounge area
  • Special diet menus

Business

  • Meeting/ Banquet facilities

Children

  • Cots
  • Children's menu
  • Game room

Spa & Leisure

  • Saltwater pool
  • Seasonal outdoor pool
  • Heated swimming pool
  • Beach access
  • Sun loungers
  • Sun terrace
  • Garden area
  • Spa & wellness centre
  • Sauna
  • Steam room
  • Beauty treatment
  • Back massage
  • Full body massage
  • Pool with view
  • Shallow end

Room view

  • Water view

Room features

  • Air conditioning
  • Heating
  • Terrace
  • Garden furniture
  • Tea and coffee facilities
  • Ironing facilities
Show all facilitiesHide facilities

Essential information about The Pridwin Hotel

💵 Lowest room price 456 C$
📏 Distance to centre 1.0 km
🗺️ Location rating 9.4
✈️ Distance to airport 85.4 km
🧳 Nearest airport Long Island MacArthur, ISP

Location
street view

Address
The address has been copied.
81 Shore Road, Shelter Island, New York, United States, 11964
Map view
Explore hotel location on the panorama
street view
81 Shore Road, Shelter Island, New York, United States, 11964
  • City landmarks
  • Nearby
  • Restaurants
  • Hotels nearby
Shelter Island Tennis Club
400 m
Restaurant
The Pridwin Restaurant
10 m

Reviews of The Pridwin Hotel

8.6 /10
Great
Verified reviews  
All reviews shown are from real guest experiences. Only travelers who have booked a stay with us can submit a review. We verify reviews according to our guidelines and publish all reviews, positive or negative.

What guests liked

powered by AI, based on real reviews

Waterfront views, family-friendly activities, and a varied dining experience enhance The Pridwin's appeal.

Read more+

Top rated Dining

Guests rate the Dining 9/10

Categories:

Rooms and cleanliness8
Here's what guests said:
“Rooms feature immaculate decor, comfortable beds, and stocked refrigerators for convenience and enjoyment.”
Location8
Here's what guests said:
“Nestled in Shelter Island, offers access to recreational activities and beautiful beach areas.”
Dining9
Here's what guests said:
“Offers delicious steak, BBQ nights, and complimentary breakfast options with fresh ingredients.”
Price and service6
Here's what guests said:
“Value noted despite higher prices; check-in delays due to staff inexperience mentioned.”
Guest reviewsWrite a Review
  • J
    J.
    United States
    left 1 review
    Wrote a review on 20 Oct
    Perfect
    Recommends the hotel
    Location10.0
    Rooms9.0
    Service8.0
    Dining9.0
    9.0
    delicious meals
    breathtaking views

    the pridwin is a charming getaway with breathtaking views of the water. we enjoyed our delicious meals, and the staff were incredibly attentive! the spa services were a delightful touch that made our stay even more enjoyable.

    Water View Room
  • R
    Ross
    United States
    left 1 review
    Wrote a review on 11 Oct
    Perfect
    Recommends the hotel
    Location10.0
    Rooms10.0
    Service10.0
    Dining10.0
    10
    attentive staff

    Family with children visit worth it

    We had an absolute blast with the kids , activities everywhere from volleyball to pumpkin painting. Nick and Rahal made our stay special with their attentiveness , felt like royalty during our dinners by the water.

    It definitely wasn’t cheap , but it was still acceptable for the great memories we made.

    Two-bedroom Cottage
  • F
    Francis
    United States
    left 1 review
    Wrote a review on 01 Oct
    Perfect
    Recommends the hotel
    Location9.0
    Rooms9.0
    Service8.0
    Dining9.0
    9.0
    sunset view
    outdoor swimming pool
    complimentary snacks
    slow check-in

    We had such a relaxing time at the hotel. the beautiful room came with a lovely sunset view and the complimentary snacks were a nice surprise! The outdoor swimming pool and garden area were perfect for unwinding after a long day. The only minor hiccup was that our check-in took a little longer than expected, but it didn’t put a damper on our stay. 🏖️

    Water View Room
  • D
    Dale
    United States
    left 11 reviews
    Wrote a review on 30 Sept
    Nice
    Doesn't recommend the hotel
    Location8.0
    Rooms7.0
    Service5.0
    Dining6.0
    6.0
    waterfront dining
    slow check-in
    inexperienced staff

    Beautiful waterfront dining options enhance the experience.

    The check-in process was infuriatingly slow, causing a frustrating start to our stay. The staff seemed inexperienced and unsure, which made everything take longer than it should have. Additionally, the concierge's lack of follow-through on our requests left us feeling neglected and disappointed.

    Hillside Room
  • E
    Elizabeth
    United States
    left 6 reviews
    Wrote a review on 05 Sept
    Perfect
    Recommends the hotel
    Location10.0
    Rooms9.0
    Service8.0
    Dining9.0
    9.0
    comfortable bed
    juicy steak
    check-in delay
    long wait
    limited meal options

    Staying in a Hillside Room exceeded my expectations, especially with the immaculate decor and the comfort of the bed. The delightful surprise of free cold drinks and snacks made the experience even better. Dining here is a treat. the juicy steak for dinner was particularly standout, paired with cocktails of superior quality. While the check-in process took a bit longer than anticipated, the beautiful and peaceful surroundings made it worthwhile.

    Hillside Room
  • D
    Daniel
    United States
    left 8 reviews
    Wrote a review on 22 Aug
    Great
    Recommends the hotel
    Location10.0
    Rooms8.0
    Service9.0
    Dining7.0
    8.0
    beautiful views
    family-friendliness

    Family getaway with a touch of class

    Made some lovely memories with the kids. The beach access was fantastic, nestled next to some real beauty and tranquility that I appreciated.

    It wasn't exactly inexpensive, but it was still okay for what we received.

    Water View Room
  • A
    Ann
    United States
    left 1 review
    Wrote a review on 23 Jul
    Great
    Recommends the hotel
    Location8.0
    Rooms9.0
    Service7.0
    Dining9.0
    8.0
    seasonal outdoor pool
    fantastic restaurant

    This place suits me perfectly with its free Wi-Fi, seasonal outdoor pool, and fantastic restaurant. On my first stay, the staff helped me find parking, which I remember fondly. Highly recommend trying the full body massage—it's amazing! I’m coming back for a business trip.

    Water View Room
  • W
    William
    United States
    left 1 review
    Wrote a review on 22 Jul
    Nice
    Doesn't recommend the hotel
    Location8.0
    Rooms7.0
    Service5.0
    Dining6.0
    6.0
    free wi-fi
    game room
    slow service

    Free Wi-Fi everywhere and enjoyed the fun game room, but the slow service frustrated us.

    Hillside Room
  • C
    Carolyn
    United States
    left 2 reviews
    Wrote a review on 14 Jul
    Perfect
    Recommends the hotel
    Location10.0
    Rooms10.0
    Service8.0
    Dining5.0
    9.0
    stunning views
    slow check-in

    Water views were stunning, but check-in took longer than expected.

    Water View Room
  • O
    Oscar
    United States
    left 3 reviews
    Wrote a review on 12 Jul
    Perfect
    Recommends the hotel
    Location10.0
    Rooms8.0
    Service10.0
    Dining9.0
    9.0
    gorgeous views
    welcoming staff

    enjoy serene views while relaxing by the pool, delightful experience for families!

    The atmosphere at Pridwin was enchanting! We loved the gorgeous views and how welcoming the staff was.

    Hillside Room

FAQ about The Pridwin Hotel

How far is The Pridwin Hotel hotel from the city centre?
Shelter Island city centre is reachable within a 15-minute walk from The Pridwin Hotel hotel.
What are the top attractions to visit while staying at the The Pridwin Hotel?
Staying at the The Pridwin Hotel, you will be within 15 minutes' drive of Horton Point Lighthouse Nautical Museum and 3.6 km from Fireboat Firefighter Museum. If you are willing to explore even more landmarks in Shelter Island, consider checking out Sylvester Manor Educational Farm set 3.4 km away.
Is there a parking at the 4-star The Pridwin Hotel?
Yes, the 4-star The Pridwin Hotel features a car park on site.
Can I have breakfast at The Pridwin Hotel?
Yes, guests can enjoy breakfast, served daily in the restaurant of The Pridwin Hotel.
What time is check-in and check-out at the Shelter Island hotel?
Guests of the Shelter Island hotel can check in from 16:00 to 23:59 and check out from 11:00.
How much does it cost to stay at the hotel?
The price for a room in the hotel starts at $334.
What payment methods are available in the The Pridwin Hotel hotel?
At the The Pridwin Hotel hotel, you can pay using Visa, American Express, and Mastercard.
What room types are available at the 4-star The Pridwin Hotel hotel?
King Room, Quadruple Room, and Guest Room are among the room types available at the 4-star The Pridwin Hotel hotel.
Which amenities are included in the rooms at The Pridwin Hotel?
Most rooms of The Pridwin Hotel include a terrace and a sitting area as well as complimentary wireless internet and cable channels.
What spa facilities does The Pridwin Hotel offer?
Pampering amenities in The Pridwin Hotel include a steam room and a sauna.
Is there a swimming pool in The Pridwin Hotel hotel?
Yes, The Pridwin Hotel hotel features a seasonal outdoor pool.
Check rooms and rates
Check-in
Select date
-
Check-out
Select date
Rooms and Guests2 Guests, 1 room